Skip Navigation

Rockbridge Academy Blog

Posts Tagged "books"

Why Do We Read Hard Books?

February 09, 2022
By JD Head, Upper School Literature Teacher

Paradise Lost. The first three times that I attempted to read this book on my own, I failed, never making it out of book 2. I was a literature teacher with several years of experience and at the beginning of my happy career at Rockbridge on my third failed attempt.

It’s a hard book. It’s a hard book, and Milton’s classical allusions, Latinate constructions, and theological asides were completely overwhelming to me, so I quit. I remember waiting at Annapolis Honda for my Civic’s oil change, trying to make sense of the thing. I finally abandoned the poem and comforted myself by asserting that “the Emperor has no clothes”: nothing that was this hard to slog through could be worth it.

 And yet…

It is largely my fault that Paradise Lost is in our present 9th grade curriculum; I made my case to Ralph Janikowski and Mike McKenna in 2010, worked to maneuver Pilgrim’s Progress into the 8th grade curriculum to make room for Milton, and then, in the fall of 2011… My class load was reduced, I stopped teaching freshman literature, and I did not have the chance to teach the book for the next seven years. My deepest regret about that? Not having a chance to read Milton’s epic with Rockbridge students again.

            And again.

            And again.

            Because it was a hard book, and it was worth it.

So let me address the question above: Why do we read hard books? 

I freely acknowledge that, for their age and relative maturity, Paradise Lost is the hardest book in our curriculum for the students tasked with reading it… and then writing about it. I also acknowledge that, as I defend it, I am doing so from a place of sympathy: I know that it is hard, since I abandoned it several times myself.

Allow me first to challenge the assumption behind the question: “hard” is not the problem.

One of my favorite lines from A Tale of Two Cities describes Charles Darnay’s condition in London. The child of French aristocrats, he abandons their life and the wealth that came with it, moves to London under an assumed name, and is now making his way as a tutor. Dickens writes, “He had expected labour, and he had found it, and did it, and made the best of it. In this, his prosperity consisted.” As anyone who has read the book would know, the life of Darnay – with its labor, with its lower middle class trappings – is infinitely more rich than that of the aristocrats he left behind, at their ease but succumbing to their “leprosy of unreality.”

He chose a harder life not because it was hard, but because it was good.

And Paradise Lost, I will consistently argue, is good. Hard, but good.

In fact, looked at the right way, “hard” is just another way of acknowledging that the task involves cost: time, effort, the restructuring of the mind to grasp what is going on.

Thus, calling something “hard” is not so strongly negative as it first appears. In fact, looked at the right way, “hard” is just another way of acknowledging that the task involves cost: time, effort, the restructuring of the mind to grasp what is going on.

(An aside: what is the greatest benefit of math for any student? That it restructures the mind to think in a more organized, balanced, direct fashion. The constant query of, “When are we ever going to use this in real life?” thus entirely misses the point. In a very particular way, it does not matter if you ever use the quadratic equation again in your life; what you have gained is an ever-deepening ability to think clearly and appreciate something beautiful.) 

Video games, which take us where we want to go anyway, are easy, and they alter the mind just as surely as potato chips alter my waistline. Healthy alteration of the mind is hard – as is the alteration of a pot-belly into abs of steel. The better abs, though, are not just useful for attracting a mate; they are actually a by-product of something that is just better for living: a healthy, fit body.

And struggling through math or Milton – leaning into the labor of it – can help to bring about that which is even more useful: a healthy, fit mind.

But people with abs of steel can be insufferably vain: this is true (I say this as a distinctly pot-bellied man). Is the goal of reading a hard book being able to look good because of my heightened mental acuity, just in time for next fall’s academic season? Of course not; the goal is to be able to get at the Truth, the goodness, the beauty that these works contain.

Greater minds than mine have defended the hard books of our curriculum for the goodness, beauty, and Truth found in them. I will add nothing to that here. I will confess that sometimes the complaint that “these books are too hard” arises because these books confront us with our own feebleness in the presence of something great (I write this as a confession of my own sins), and we have developed a society that tears down that which is great. Instead, we should see that, like a good, hard practice under the hot, August sun, the hard book prepares us for that which is even greater, for understanding and thinking more deeply, for going “further up and further in”.

Because the Bible, too, is a hard book, and we abandon the reading of it at our peril.

Instead, we should see that, like a good, hard practice under the hot, August sun, the hard book prepares us for that which is even greater, for understanding and thinking more deeply, for going “further up and further in”.

 

Posted in Upper School

Summer Book List

June 23, 2020
By Emily Marsh

Author: Emily Marsh, class of2019

Emily is excited to build the Rockbridge Blog to highlight the community that educated and guided her. She is now studying Economics at Hillsdale College, where she’s a captain of the sailing team and an editor of the Hillsdale Blog.

Summary: Every year, Rockbridge Academy released a summer book list for her students. This year, these lists seem more critical than ever.

Across the country, families’ summer plans have changed drastically this year. In the wake of canceled sleepaway camps and postponed vacations, summer reading will claim its place more than ever as a critical defense against the creeping summer malaise. The Great Books broaden horizons when travel isn’t an option and don’t require any social distancing. Our literature department has compiled a list of some such books for the student body to tackle this summer; here’s a sampling of them:

GRAMMAR

  • Amelia Bedelia — Peggy Parish
  • Corduroy — Don Freeman
  • Curious George — H. A. Rey
  • Frog and Toad are Friends — Arnold Lobel
  • The Garden of Abdul Gasazi  — Van Allsburg, Chris
  • How the Leopard Got His Claws — Chinua Achebe
  • Madeline — Ludwig Bemelmans
  • Mr. Popper’s Penguins — Richard and Florence Atwater
  • Pippi Longstocking — Astrid Lindgren
  • Shiloh — Phyllis Reynolds Naylor
  • The Story of Babar — Jean de Brunhoff
  • The Tale of Peter Rabbit — Beatrix Potter
  • Where the Wild Things Are — Maurice Sendak
  • Anne of Green Gables — L. M. Montgomery
  • Chronicles of Prydain — Lloyd Alexander
  • The Chronicles of Narnia — C. S. Lewis
  • D’Aulaire’s Book of Norse Myths — Ingri and Edgar d’Aulaire
  • Harriet the Spy — Lousie Fitshugh
  • Hatchet — Gary Paulsen
  • The Jungle Book — Rudyard Kipling
  • Mary Poppings — Pamela I. Travers
  • Matilda — Ronald Dahl
  • Misty of Chincoteague — Marguerite Henry
  • The Secret Garden — France Hodgson Burnett
  • Swiss Family Robinson — Johann Wyss
  • The Wonderful Wizard of Oz — L. Frank Baum
  • Tuck Everlasting — Natalie Babbitt

Dialectic:

  • King Arthur and His Knights of the Round Table — Roger Lancelyn Green
  • The Adventures of Tom Sawyer — Mark Twain
  • The Enchanted Castle — E. Nesbit
  • A Tree Grows in Brooklyn — Betty Smith
  • A Wrinkle in Time, Series — Madeline L’Engle
  • Alas, Babylon — Pat Frank
  • Novels — Agatha Christie
  • Hound of the Baskervilles — Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
  • Ender’s Game — Orson Scott Card
  • Little Women — Louisa May Alcott
  • Profiles in Courage — John F. Kennedy
  • Gaudy Night — Dorothy Sayers
  • The Lord of the Flies — William Golding
  • The Martian Chronicles — Ray Bradbury
  • The Scarlet Pimpernel — Baroness Orczy
  • To Kill a Mockingbird — Harper Lee
  • Treasure Island — Robert L. Stevenson
  • Amazing Grace — Eric Metaxas
  • Fahrenheit 451 — Ray Bradbury
  • Frankenstein — Mary Shelley
  • My Early Life — Winston Churchill
  • Raft — Stephen Baxter
  • Robinson Crusoe — Daniel Defoe
  • The Lord of the Rings, Trilogy — J. R. R. Tolkien
  • The Three Musketeers — Alexander Dumas

RHETORIC

  • The Music of Pythagoras — Kitty Ferguson
  • The Source — James A. Michener
  • Complete Sherlock Holmes — Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
  • How Should We Then Live? — Francis Schaeffer
  • The Killer Angels — Michael Shaara
  • Mere Christianity, Abolition of Man, Screwtape Letters — C. S. Lewis
  • Notes from the Tilt-a-Whirl — N. B. Wilson
  • The Old Man and the Sea — Ernest Hemingway
  • Things Fall Apart — Chinua Achebe
  • Uncle Tom’s Cabin — Harriet Beecher Stowe
  • The Chosen — Chaim Potok
  • Isaac Newton — James Gleick
  • Mathematics: Is God Silent? — James Nickel
  • Autobiography — Benjamin Franklin
  • Thee Confession, City of God — St. Augustine
  • The Count of Monte Cristo — Alexandre Dumas
  • East of Eden — John Steinbeck
  • The Good Earth — Pearl S. Buck      
  • He Leadeth Me — Walter Ciszek
  • Heart of Darkness — Joseph Conrad
  • The Last of the Mohicans — James Fenimore Cooper
  • North and South — Elizabeth Gaskell
  • Anna Karenina, War and Peace — Leo Tolstoy
  • Les Miserables — Victor Hugo
  • Middlemarch — George Eliot

These books represent some of the Great Books, spanning many different eras of literature, that have shaped Western thought and informed much of its progress. Classical education depends on both looking around ourselves at contemporary works and on looking backwards to the great works that have come before. They may report ideas that deserve a meticulous perusal or describe a completely unfamiliar world, but above all else, they offer enchanting stories that have captivated many generations of learners and will continue to captivate readers. 

Posted in School Culture

Recent Posts

5/26/22 - By Rachel Fix
4/28/22 - By Sarah Soltis, Class of 2020
4/12/22 - By Emily Scheie, Upper School Literature Teacher and Middle School Cross Country Coach
3/30/22 - By Nathan Daly '19
3/17/22 - By Noelle McDowell '22

Categories

Archives